Both Nokia and Sony Ericsson are my top phone choice. I don’t see myself using other phone type except Siemens. This is because these trios manufacture highly functional and data-centric phones, starting from Nokia and then closely followed by Sony Ericsson. When I consider a phone, I look at it purely from the business function of it. Any other feature is an added advantage, but not necessarily a pre-requisite for purchasing the phone. I hardly use the digital camera on my phones. What for? If I need to take good pictures, I will make use of my 5 Megapixel HP camera. This is why a phone like Nokia 9300i will appeal more to me than Nokia N93 with its 3.15 Megapixel camera and Carl Zeiss optics.
The Nokia E61 and Sony Ericsson M600 Smartphones are by no means the best phones from their respective manufacturers. All the same, they are designed with the business end-users in mind, and that explains the absence of a camera. This is no issue if you are no camera aficionado or your work place permits no camera. Similar in function, the two phones differ a little in some areas. The chart below compares the two phones based on their specifications.
| Nokia E61 | SE M600 | |
| Weight (g) | 144 | 112 |
| Dimensions (mm) | 117 x 69.7 x 14 | 107 x 57 x 15 |
| Display Type | TFT, 16M colors | FT touchscreen, 256K colors |
| Display Size (pixels) | 320 x 240
pixels, 58 x 45 mm |
240 x 320
pixels, 39 x 53 mm |
| QWERTY Keyboard | Yes, Full | Yes |
| Vibrate | Yes | Yes |
| Camera / Video | No | No |
| OS | Symbian OS 9.1, Series 60 UI | Symbian OS v9.1, UIQ 3.0 |
| Shared Memory (MB) | 75 | 80 |
| Card Slot |
MiniSD, 64 MB card included |
Memory Stick Micro (M2), 64 MB card included |
| GPRS | Yes | Yes |
| Infrared | Yes | Yes |
| USB | Yes, Port-Port | Yes, v2.0 |
| Bluetooth | Yes, v1.2 | Yes, v2.0 |
| WLAN | Yes, VoIP over WLAN | No |
| 3G | Yes | Yes |
| EDGE | Yes | No |
| HSCSD | No | Yes |
| FM Stereo | No | No |
| Media Player | MP3/AAC/MPEG4 | Media Player (MP3, AAC) |
| Browser | WAP 2.0/xHTML, HTML |
HTML (Opera v8), RSS Reader |
| Office Applications | Yes | Yes |
| Others | Blackeberry Connectivity | Handwriting Recognition (English & Chinese) |
Comments
The Nokia E61 seems to have all the connectivity option (including WLAN) with the exception of HSCSD. For a truly business mobile phone, Wi-Fi connectivity is essential. The Sony Ericsson lacks Wi-Fi but has the HSCSD connectivity instead.
The Nokia E61 is bigger and heavier than the Sony Ericsson M600, but has a bigger screen area. This is great for documents or eBooks reading. The SE M600 is smaller and lighter. The smaller size of the SE M600 makes it the smallest Smartphone of the manufacturer. It is highly pocketable without creating a budge in the pocket.
Nokia E61 features a full QWERTY keyboard which makes it great for typing messages or editing documents. However, the QWERTY feature of the Sony Ericsson M600 is half-way, with a button sharing two characters of the alphabets. This by no means reduces the functionality of the keyboard, but it needs a little adapting to.
Finally
A choice between the two Smartphones depends on individual preference between a choice of Wi-Fi and a bigger screen or no Wi-Fi, but a smaller and pocketable Smartphone. Either choice, both phones are great business phones. That brings up the question at the back of my mind, “Can’t we get a perfect phone for once?â€
Nokia E61 & Sony Ericsson M600

Sony Ericsson T650, S500 & T250 Handsets
Nokia 1200, 1208 & 1650 handsets
Nokia 2660, 2630 & 2760 handsets
Sony Ericsson P1 Smartphone
Blackberry 8830 World Edition
RSS feed






